Best for…
This is the best of the roller models we tested at blocking light, and it comes in several colors and a good price.
It’s simple and chic, and it works. The iFit Cordless Blackout Roller Shade sports an acrylic-coated polyester that looks sleek and feels pleasant to the touch while completely blocking light. Unlike cheaper roller shades, it moves smoothly, without suddenly snapping up or drooping.
It comes in a modest range of neutral colors. Most other options in this price category offer only variations of white, but this one also comes in gray and (on Blinds.com) brown.
You can ditch the hand vac. Like other roller shades, this one has a flat design you can easily wipe down with a damp cloth. You won’t have to dust as much either.
Flaws but not dealbreakers
This shade won’t insulate from noise or temperature. Without the honeycomb construction of cellular shades (such as our top pick and upgrade pick), the iFit doesn’t help isolate your home from outside noise or temperatures.
You might need an outside mount. The fabric panel is 1.25 inches narrower than the rod so it can roll up and down without hitting the sides of your window frame. The catch? Despite the panel’s complete-blackout capabilities, hanging the shade inside the frame may allow light to enter through the top and sides, creating a halo effect. If this bothers you, you can add a valance or curtains, or simply install your shades outside the window frame. (You have the option of either an inside or outside mount when you order.)
Not all retailers provide the same sizing customization. You can buy iFit shades at Home Depot or Blinds.com. If you shop at Home Depot, where you may be able to sample the shades in person, you must choose from sizes that differ by only half-inch increments. This could make it harder to get a snug interior fit, causing more light to sneak in. However, Blinds.com offers sizing increments of an eighth of an inch.
Key specs
Dimensions: Width, 22 to 73 inches; height, 12 by 74 inches
Colors: six neutrals at Blinds.com; varies elsewhere
